Nova Wealth
The Ultimate What to do When Switching Your Financial Advisor Checklist
Blog

The Ultimate What to do When Switching Your Financial Advisor Checklist

April 29, 2026

PART 1: Decide If Your Advisor Is Failing You (1–20)

1. Pull your last 3 years of account statements and calculate your actual net annual return after fees → Tool: PortfolioVisualizer.com

2. Compare your returns to a simple 3-fund portfolio benchmark

→ Tool: Vanguard Total Market + International + Bond index

3. List every product you own and mark which ones have front-load, back-load, or surrender charges

4. Find your advisor’s compensation structure in writing (AUM %, commissions, revenue sharing)

5. Search your advisor on FINRA BrokerCheck and SEC IAPD

6. Check if your advisor is legally a fiduciary 100% of the time

7. Calculate your total expense ratio (TER) across all accounts

8. Identify how much of your portfolio is in actively managed funds

9. Determine if your asset allocation has changed at all in the last 5 years

10. List every time your advisor proactively contacted you vs you contacting them

11. Check if your advisor explained tax consequences of trades in advance

12. Verify if your advisor used financial planning software or “rules of thumb”

13. Look for over-diversification (more than 25–30 holdings in mutual funds alone)

14. Identify any products you don’t fully understand — flag them

15. Calculate how much you paid your advisor last year in dollars, not percentages

16. Compare advisor-recommended funds to ETF equivalents

17. Check if your advisor suggested insurance as an investment

18. Look for cash drag (idle cash earning near zero)

19. Confirm whether Roth planning was ever discussed

20. Ask yourself: If I fired them today, would my plan still be clear?

PART 2: Safely Prepare to Leave (21–40)

21. Download all statements, tax forms, and trade confirmations

22. Get a full holdings report with cost basis

23. Confirm which assets are portable and which are not

24. Identify surrender periods on annuities or insurance products

25. Confirm whether accounts are held at a custodian (Schwab, Fidelity, Vanguard)

26. Check if your advisor controls login access — reclaim it

27. Turn off any automatic reinvestment changes temporarily

28. Create a list of account types (IRA, Roth, taxable, 401k, trust)

29. Verify beneficiary designations are correct

30. Document your current investment policy statement (even if informal)

31. Check if any positions have short-term capital gains risk

32. Identify positions with large unrealized gains

33. Determine whether liquidation would trigger tax cliffs

34. Export performance history to CSV

35. Screenshot your asset allocation pie chart

36. Confirm whether advisor has discretionary trading authority

37. Remove advisor from account permissions

38. Open a blank account at a new custodian (no transfer yet)

39. Pause new contributions until transition plan is clear

40. Set a clean exit date

PART 3: Rebuild Your Retirement Plan (41–65)

41. Calculate your retirement number using multiple scenarios → Tool: OpenSocialSecurity.com

42. Map expected income streams (Social Security, pensions, rentals)

43. Build a withdrawal order strategy (taxable → tax-deferred → Roth)

44. Choose a target equity/bond allocation based on timeline, not age

45. Stress test your plan against sequence-of-returns risk

46. Decide between 4% rule vs dynamic withdrawals

47. Evaluate Roth conversion ladders

→ Tool: Roth Conversion Calculator (Bogleheads)

48. Determine ideal cash buffer in retirement

49. Set rebalancing rules (calendar-based or threshold-based)

50. Choose a low-cost ETF lineup (max 5–7 funds)

51. Evaluate if TIPS belong in your plan

52. Model inflation scenarios at 2%, 4%, and 6%

53. Account for healthcare costs pre-Medicare

54. Decide if long-term care insurance is necessary

55. Run Monte Carlo simulations with conservative assumptions

56. Build a one-page retirement dashboard

57. Create a glide path instead of static allocation

58. Define rules for market crashes before they happen

59. Document when you would reduce risk

60. Document when you would increase risk

61. Decide how often you review the plan (quarterly, annually)

62. Automate contributions and rebalancing

63. Write a personal “investment discipline contract”

64. Store everything in one secure digital location

65. Confirm your plan works without any advisor intervention

PART 4: Choose a Better Advisor (If You Want One) (66–85)

66. Decide if you actually need advice, coaching, or execution

67. Filter only fee-only fiduciary advisors

68. Prefer flat-fee or hourly over AUM when possible

69. Ask for a sample financial plan

70. Ask how they handle down markets

71. Ask how they optimize tax location

72. Ask how many clients they serve per advisor

73. Ask what they don’t do

74. Verify credentials (CFP, CPA, CFA)

75. Ask how they measure success

76. Confirm they do not sell products

77. Ask for their investment philosophy in writing

78. Ask how often the plan is updated

79. Ask what happens if you leave them

80. Ask how they handle Roth planning

81. Ask if they custody assets themselves (red flag)

82. Ask for real examples of mistakes they’ve made

83. Confirm no lock-in contracts

84. Compare their cost vs DIY cost

85. Decide if peace of mind is worth the fee

PART 5: Execute the Switch Cleanly (86–100)

86. Initiate ACAT transfer at new custodian

87. Choose in-kind transfer vs liquidation

88. Confirm no taxable events were triggered

89. Re-establish automatic investments

90. Rebuild your allocation if needed

91. Confirm cost basis transferred correctly

92. Set up performance tracking

93. Update beneficiaries again

94. Update estate documents if needed

95. Review plan after 90 days

96. Compare new costs vs old costs

97. Track behavior improvements (panic reduction)

98. Write a post-mortem on the old advisor relationship

99. Create a personal “never again” checklist

100. Schedule your annual self-audit